REAL WORK. REAL STORIES. REAL PEOPLE.
All articles

Fieldcraft / Materials & application

Know Your Sealers: Types, Tradeoffs & Application

Coal tar, asphalt emulsion, acrylic, and gilsonite. How to think about their differences before choosing a product.

If I could show you my DMs, you'd probably be surprised by how many questions I get about sealcoating. I try to answer every one. A lot of contractors are simply looking for a clear explanation of what they're buying and why one product might behave differently from another.

So let's talk about four common types: coal-tar-based, asphalt emulsion, acrylic, and gilsonite. I'm leaving brand names out of it and focusing on the broad differences.

Each has a different composition and its own application considerations. The actual temperature limits, dilution, surface preparation, traffic reopening time, and environmental requirements depend on the specific product and location. The manufacturer's written instructions should always win over general advice.

Coal-Tar Based Sealer

Composition: These products use coal-tar-derived materials with water, fillers, and other additives to create a coating designed to protect pavement.

Application: Depending on the formulation, crews may use a squeegee, spray system, or brush. Start with a clean, prepared surface, follow the specified coat and cure requirements, and keep traffic off until the product is ready.

Notes: Coal-tar products have been valued for resistance to some automotive fluids, but handling precautions and environmental restrictions are important considerations. Check local rules and the product's safety documentation before purchasing or applying them.

Asphalt Emulsion Sealers

Composition: Asphalt emulsion products use asphalt binder dispersed in water, often with fillers and additives selected for the intended performance.

Application: A squeegee, spray system, or brush may be suitable depending on the product. Surface cleanliness, moisture, shade, temperature, and the forecast all deserve attention. Large jobs often benefit from spray equipment, but the application method still needs to match the specification.

Notes: Asphalt emulsion products are a common choice for contractors who want a water-based option. Performance and handling characteristics vary between formulations. For me and my crew, the working conditions and handling requirements are part of the buying decision.

Acrylic Sealers

Composition: Acrylic coatings use acrylic polymers and may include additives for color retention, texture, or other specialized performance needs.

Application: Manufacturers specify which tools to use, the surface conditions needed, and the correct film thickness. Some acrylic systems dry relatively quickly, but that is not a reason to skip the specified curing window.

Notes: Acrylic products are often considered for specialized uses and finishes. Evaluate them by the specific job requirements, not simply by whether they cost more.

I also get questions about gilsonite. I used a gilsonite product early in my career and liked the application experience. As my business scaled, it wasn't a practical fit for our market and the local rules we had to follow.

Gilsonite Sealers

Composition: Gilsonite is a naturally occurring asphaltite. Products sold as gilsonite sealers use that material in a formulation designed for pavement application; ingredients and solvent systems vary.

Application: Application tools, weather limits, and drying requirements are product-specific. Review the safety documentation, check local restrictions, and follow the written instructions closely.

Notes: Some formulations produce a deep-black finish, which is part of their appeal. Whether the product is suitable for a particular pavement depends on the condition of that pavement, the product's stated use, and local requirements.

The important thing is knowing why you're choosing a product. Ask your supplier questions, read the technical data sheet and safety information, understand your local regulations, and make sure the sealer fits the conditions your crew actually works in.

More from the field.

All articles